Articles written for Kuro5hin.org, osOpinion.com, and occasionally Slashdot.org.
NOTE (09/10/03): osOpinion.com is down
right now. I have kept the original links,
but added links (marked "[CACHE]") that point to copies I pulled from Google's cache.
For the moment, use the [CACHE] links, the others won't work. Links to comments
at osOpinion.com won't work at all, unfortunately.
From its humble beginnings as an
idea I had last year, the Open Data Format Initiative has now become a full-fledged
web site, where I offer my commentary on the philosophy of ODFI, discussion
of various open source bills, and lots of other good stuff. The coming out party
was today, when I picked up a link
from slashdot (submitted by myself).
05.08.03 A discussion of Microsoft Bloggers and how they might affect the future of blogging. This article was voted down when I submitted it, so I posted it as a diary entry (perhaps appropriate for an article on blogging). Interestingly, many people who read this thought that a) I was a blogger, b) I thought Microsoft was evil, and therefore c) the article was just a long whine about how Microsoft was going to ruin everything. In fact a) and b) are false, and I am neither particularly for, nor particularly against, this scenario (which is only a possibility anyway). I do think blogging needs to grow up and get over the fantasy that it will replace old media.
04.23.03 I wrote a slashdot review of the book How Would You Move Mount Fuji? Microsoft's Cult of the Puzzle - How the World's Smartest Company Selects the Most Creative Thinkers (that's just the title, not the whole book) by William Poundstone. "A marvelously balanced and well-reasoned piece" says the author, the review generated 1175 comments at last check (only 11 of which were rated -1), and the amazon.com ranking for the book jumped from 11,722 to 29.
I posted an update to my story T.E.U.,
an improvement over the original version. Many
positive comments, including a few suggesting I write a sequel. A few links,
by Furia, Both
Barrels, and Netalive,
and badsoda (look under April 11 --
permalinks are broken on that site).
I start the new year off with some speculation on What
the Future Holds for Microsoft. An idle comment about Linux being hopeless
on the desktop generates a significant portion of the discussion, but some
interesting back-and-forth in there. The Guardian
Online's blog says "...doesn't mean it's all necessarily correct, only
that it provides a lot more insight into the reality of Microsoft than most of
the junk that gets published."
12.13.02 I wrote an article a while ago called "Can We Improve Computer-to-Human Bandwidth?" for osopinion, but never submitted it. I wound up posting it as a comment on slashdot.
To support a new magazine for Princeton alumni called The
Princeton Independent, I produced a 6000-word
opus on Nunavut, the new territory covering Canada's Arctic. The magazine is
currently online-only, but did not include any links, so here are some: the Government
of Nunavut, the Indian and Northern Affairs Canada Nunavut
index, the Nunatsiaq News
newspaper, and a few of the publications I reference in the article: Colin
Irwin's report "Lords
of the Arctic, Wards of the State" (with responses), the Nunavut
Broadband Task Force report (PDF), and the Conference Board of Canada "Nunavut
Economic Outlook, May 2001" (PDF).
I compare Weight
Watchers to the Atkins Diet, a
typical low-carbohydrate diet. It seems nutritionists are starting to believe
that the benefits of the low-carb diets can outweigh the negatives.
Here is my proposal for redesigning the World
Trade Center site, the key point of which is preserving the visual impact of
the "bathtub" that was revealed when the foundations were cleared
away. Check out the drawings I did (south
looking north and east
looking west). This idea seems to have been picked up by a few of the current
on the Lower Manhattan Development Corporation's website.
I discuss how I think Microsoft shifting
revenue backwards isn't really morally superior to shifting it forwards (a
la Worldcom etc), but nobody seems to have picked up on this.
On a non-computer-related note, I discuss that what people are looking for in
the suburbs might actually be better
found in cities.
OK, back to kuro5hin...this is a little history of TCPA
and Palladium, in which I blame most of it on Microsoft's fear of Sony. This
article was linked to by several
places, one of which was Ross Anderson's somewhat alarmist TCPA/Palladium
With all the fuss over middleware these days, it's not clear there's much to get
excited about (part 1
[CACHE] and part 2
is making any money off of middleware these days, and nobody has any plans to
make money, so who cares who controls any particular language/media
format/instant messenger protocol/whatever. The discussion about this article
included canonical versions of the Microsoft
was mean to Apple and Microsoft
was mean to Digital Research arguments.
Bill Gates insisted during his testimony in the nine states antitrust trial that
modular Windows was impossible without a lot of work. But what about Windows XP
Embedded, which would appear to be a modular version of Windows? Well, it's not
quite that simple [CACHE]. This article was linked
to extensively, including some actual
After seeing the movie Revolution OS,
I whipped up a review
for slashdot. "The film by J.T.S. Moore is about the growth of the free
software movement, and its eventual co-option by the open source movement. I
don't think that's what the movie was supposed to be about; it was supposed to
be about Linux and its battle about Microsoft. But the movie is quickly hijacked
by its participants and turned into a theoretical discussion, in which Linux
itself is a mere sideshow."
I talk about how Microsoft is still baffled
by Unix [CACHE]. The company keeps doing dopey things when competing with Unix. I
discuss who is to blame for this, the developers or the program managers. HINT:
I was a developer. That is not a typical Microsoft marketing person on the cover
of the book
there, but it might as well be.
I discuss source code and patents (parts one
[CACHE] and two
the basic point that if you want to see the former (which I do), you are going
to need to allow the latter, but that you can require the former with the latter
(got that?). Also, that the data structures and algorithms behind software (the
type of things that are patentable) are much more valuable than the actual
source code (which is copyrighted). So let's see that source code folks! "The
first opinion piece Iíve seen on the site in a long time that was worth a damn,"
said one reader.
03.12.02 I talk briefly about the future need for cheap, reliable web hosting [CACHE] in the future world of .Net and Web Services. As I said in a comment, "Right now you can pay $X for some amount of bandwidth/storage, or pay $2X for five times as much bandwidth/storage, or pay $4X for 20 times as much, or whatever. What I think needs to happen is that you can pay $2X and get the same bandwidth/storage, but it has one-fifth the downtime. Or pay $4X and have one-twentieth the downtime." (Image from MosquitoNet, an Internet access company in Fairbanks, AK, of all places.)
My latest scheme is the Open
Data Format Initiative [CACHE], a plan to "encourage" all software
companies to document any data formats they use to store user data. This does
not mean that companies will have to adopt any standard format, just document
the ones they use. Let me repeat, this does not mean that companies will have to adopt any
standard format, just document the ones they use. As you can see, the
lobbying has begun! This post was discussed at InfoAnarchy
01.18.02 When reports of Bill Gates'
first came out, they claimed that one of the provisions was that employees
reviews would be based in part on their ability to write secure code. I felt
although the rest of the memo was mostly fluff, that one point showed Microsoft
was finally getting
serious about security [CACHE]. Of course in the end it turns out that those reports
were false, which proves that Microsoft is actually not yet getting serious
Inspired by articles
claiming that the future of the Internet must include micropayments, I make my
case that in fact micropayments
are a crock [CACHE]. My article was linked to by TechDirt,
which feels the same way. The drawing there on the left, incidentally, was blatantly
ripped off from a cartoon by Scott
McCloud, a two-parter
in favor of micropayments. By way of micropaying for using it, I will put in a plug
for his meta-comics,
they are both excellent.
I look over the proposed settlement of the Department of Justice to examine open
source and enforcing the agreement [CACHE]. "A close look at the agreement
reveals more than one loophole and back-door provision that could either limit
-- or enhance -- the role of open-source contributors in enforcing the deal."
Also discussed on LinuxToday.
I make the point that most of the new features in Windows XP are really just
bundled applications [CACHE]. In a comment about this article, I emphasize my most
important point, which is that just because the U.S. Appeals Court said the
Internet Explorer bundling was OK, Microsoft shouldn't necessarily get to throw
in the kitchen sink.
Triggered by a Microsoft employee bitching
and moaning about people who publish details of exploits, I talk about the arrogance
of developers [CACHE] at Microsoft and how this can lead to bugs. This is a good
time to mention that I don't get to pick the title of osOpinion articles. My
original title was "Developer Arrogance and Buffer Overflows." Gak, I
later noticed this got referenced in a footnote in one of the public
comments on the DOJ lawsuit settlement.
I consider the possibility that Linux missed
its big chance for success [CACHE] against Windows. Microsoft is about to ship an
operating system, Windows XP,
that was designed after Linux got popular. Linux can no longer benefit from
Microsoft's inattention. Check out the 200+
comments if you dare. Various places linked to this article, including Hardware
One. No surprise the indefatigable yakkers on LinuxToday
also chimed in with some suggestions I was dropped as a child. Meanwhile a high
school student reviewed
the article for a class assignment.
I wrote an article about The
Effect of War on the Economy for an obscure new discussion site called Slant-Six.
I submitted it there because I finally got fed up with the quality of discussion
on Kuro5hin. So now instead of getting many inane comments, I get no comments at
In the wake of the 9/11 terrorist attack, how did the Internet
work as a news source? "Was this the coming of age for the Internet as
a news source, the moment when it replaced traditional television news as the
best source of information in a time of crisis?"
I attended a seminar given by Edward Tufte,
in which he discussed, among other things, his ideas
on web design, which don't necessarily match those of many graphic designers
working out there.
Is it possible that e-commerce could turn out to be a waste
of money for everyone [CACHE]? That even a catalog with an 800 number like Lands'
End would probably be happier if e-commerce hadn't happened? Read on to find
I wrote a review
of the book Breaking Windows
for Slashdot. "It hopefully
shatters, once and for all, the myth that Microsoft is a hive community marching
in line behind Bill Gates."
An article discussing subscription
software and network lock-in [CACHE]. Summary: Hailstorm won't get lots of
subscribers and it won't generate sales of .NET plumbing. I will point out that
I got one example backwards: It's not "Imagine if Linux, Mac and OS/2
applications ran seamlessly on a Windows machine," but rather the notion of
Windows applications running seamlessly on any operating system, and then trying
to use Office to generate sales of Windows, that elucidates my point. Despite
this, Dave Winer still linked to this.
UPDATE 04.11.02 Microsoft has evidently
Hailstorm. Along the way it was renamed My Services and then eventually
Persona -- but who cares, it's toast for now.
07.16.01 I try to debunk a myth that has persisted for a while, that Microsoft employees wore buttons (or maybe a t-shirt) with the slogan "FYIFV" on them.
07.01.01 Microsoft just decided to remove the Smart Tags feature from IE6, but I have a suspicion that they may be back before too long [CACHE].
After my book was reviewed
on Slashdot, I couldn't help writing a little meta-review
on Kuro5hin. As rusty
said, "Fluffy? Pointless? Yes! But I thought it was entertaining as hell to
read. Anyway, it's Friday night. Crack a beer and vote +1 like it's 1999.
Here I opine on Microsoft,
TCP/IP, Open Source, and Licensing for Kuro5hin. Did I miss anything? This
was in response to the Wall
Street Journal article alleging that Microsoft was using BSD code inside its
TCP/IP stack. It talks about the history of the TCP code Microsoft has shipped,
then wraps things up by discussing what Craig Mundie is yapping about when he
complains about the GPL. According to this linkfest,
the article was written by "someone claiming to have been a Microsoft
employee." Lil' devil is from freebsd.org.
More complaining, this time about the general lameness
of search engines [CACHE]. NOTE: The "friend" in the article is actually
my father, if anyone wants to know. This one also got picked up by our friends
but I discovered those links get stale pretty quickly.
Another article for Kuro5hin, this one is superficially about me reminiscing
about Eve Andersson, a much admired and drooled-at web figure from back in
1995 (photo, as it were, at left), but in reality it is complaining about how
the current crop of blogs are too self-important for their own good. This got
linked to by JD Lasica's blog
(scroll down a bit). That's one of the good ones, of course! UPDATE
06.20.01 As a result of this, Eve invited me to a talk
about ArsDigita in Seattle this evening,
so I finally met her.
I discuss what I consider to be a real advantage
[CACHE] of open source, the fact that you don't need formal interviews that try to
simulate actually working on a project. (The picture was taken from a banner ad
I posted an article on Kuro5hin,
and Disruptive Technology, based on the book The
Innovator's Dilemma by Clayton Christensen. This article was similar to
my osOpinion articles, but it was longer than their word limit, which is why I
posted it somewhere else.
04.23.01 Spring is in the air in Redmond, and it seems like the sap is running [CACHE] at Microsoft again. This article also got picked up by Yahoo! News.
about the previous article got me thinking about the Xbox, a powerful machine
with built-in Ethernet selling for $300. I decided that the Xbox would make a
great web server [CACHE]. This article was picked up by Yahoo!
News, which led to a discussion on Slashdot.
It was also mentioned on MSXbox,
but inspired no venom. UPDATE 01.30.03
Gak! My vision of a stack of clustered Xboxes actually
Is the Xbox a good idea for
Microsoft? Independently of whether it will be profitable, I don't
think it makes sense [CACHE] for Microsoft. This column generated some good flames
when it was posted to the fan site MSXbox
(from which I lifted the logo).
Unfortunately the article was presented as me criticizing the Xbox as a
business model, when I was really criticizing Xbox as a strategic direction for
Microsoft. It was also linked to by ConsoleWire,
Radar (third item down -- they actually summarized my article reasonably
well). My offhand comment that Linux users should buy an Xbox to hurt Microsoft
generated some discussion on LinuxToday.
My new idea, inspired by
Microsoft's limited release of its source code, is that every company should
provide read-only source
[CACHE] to its software.
UPDATE 05.03.01 Has Microsoft been reading my stuff?
Here I am complaining
about themes [CACHE] aka skins. (Picture is from skinz.org.)
"A nice rant" says the giant
ant. This article was mentioned by Adam Gaffin in Network
World Fusion (fifth item down), which in turn led to an entire column by
another NWF columnist, Mark Gibbs. Gibbs disagreed with me, but he did mention
the book. For some reason, that particular column of his is not online. UPDATE
03.06.02 My article only generated 33 comments, but almost a
year later, a very
similar article [here's a copy
from the Wayback Machine] (in fact
by osOpinion honcho Kelly McNeil generated over 400 comments, most inquiring
about the size of his brainpan. This led Kelly to do an interview
with Jef Raskin supporting his point, which led to a "Can't
We All Get Along?" article.
The education begins...in
"Bridge to Linux Island" I tackle the issue of evangelism
and Linux [CACHE], which causes some discussion in the Talkback Forum. Accusations
of FUD came from LinuxToday.
the Mackinac Bridge is from its official Website.)
Why was the Anna Kournikova
email worm illegal [CACHE]?
This article was included in a Business 2.0 "Web
Guide" on computer viruses. (Picture taken from annak.org, a fan site
that actually covered the worm outbreak.)
Beyond the PC? Bah! Just a side
effect of the dot-com revolution [CACHE], I say.
I am ruminating on Interactive
Television: Where's the Beef [CACHE]? (Don't mean to pick on Microsoft per se, just
a handy logo I found.)
I managed to have an
article rejected by osOpinion-just too scandalous I
guess. (Credit slashdot.org for the
Here is a two-part article (part
1 [CACHE] and part 2
analyzing peer-to-peer network traffic in general (and pointing out what I claim
is a bug in Napster). (The logo was borrowed from the O'Reilly
is a discussion of the Napster-Bertelsmann
alliance [CACHE]. Should they be allowed to define a standard for digital music
distribution without any outside input?
I give my prediction on What
Microsoft's .NET could be [CACHE].
Back to main page.